1
Multicriteria decision making in reservoir system planning | |
Author | Shrestha, Dinesh Lal |
Call Number | AIT Diss. no. WA-91-03 |
Subject(s) | Reservoirs--Nepal--Mathematical models |
Note | A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Engineering, School of Engineering and Technology |
Publisher | Asian Institute of Technology |
Series Statement | Dissertation ; no. WA-91-03 |
Abstract | The development of reservoir systems for optimum utilization of water resources calls for careful and articulate planning. While acknowledging the important role of systems methodology in the analysis, one should understand the inherent limitations of the conventional models when applied to real problems. The model should be developed to suit the needs and particular characteristics of the system as close as possible so as to meet the stipulated objectives. These aspects have been considered for the planning of the reservoir system in the Karnali river basin, Nepal. The Chisapani project, the largest single reservoir system in the basin, has been given considerable interests by the concerned authorities in the recent years. However, several relatively smaller reservoirs can be developed in the upper reaches of the basin and a number of alternative plans can be formed among these to yield benefits close to that of the Chisapani project. Moreover, these smaller reservoirs apparently have less adverse environmental and social impacts. Stochastic Dynamic Programming (SDP) and simulation models have been developed to evaluate the optimal firm energy capabilities and other performance measures of the alternatives. The information required for environmental parameters have been processed and calculated using a Geographic Information System (GIS). The fuzzy inference theory has been formulated for the assessment of the relative index values of reservoir induced mass erosion. The selection of the "best" alternative reservoir system plan has been achieved through a multicriteria analysis in which four criteria; cost, benefit, environmental impact, and social impact indicators have been considered. In order to encode the fuzziness in the available data sets and in the decision making process involving human judgement, the concept of Fuzzy Decision Analysis (FDA) has been implemented in the proposed Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques. The enhanced compromise solution to MCDM, fuzzy decision making under certainty and fuzzy inference based MCDM have been formulated and applied to the present problem. The approach and methodologies employed in the present planning problem of the reservoir system appear to be promising for other cases as well. The proposed methods for the MCDM analysis are comparatively simple and easy to understand, yet address the underlying characteristics of the real world problems to a greater extent. This study confirms that the Chisapani project is not a superior alternative given the present decision situation. From the point of view of the analyst, a group of three best alternative systems comprising smaller reservoirs have been recommended. |
Year | 1991 |
Corresponding Series Added Entry | Asian Institute of Technology. Dissertation ; no. WA-91-03 |
Type | Dissertation |
School | School of Engineering and Technology |
Department | Other Field of Studies (No Department) |
Academic Program/FoS | Water Resources Research Engineering (WA) |
Chairperson(s) | Paudyal, Guna N. ;Harboe, Ricardo ; |
Examination Committee(s) | Gupta, Ashim Das ;Tabucanon, Mario T. ;Kindler, Janusz ; |
Scholarship Donor(s) | The Government of Australia; |
Degree | Thesis (Ph.D.) - Asian Institute of Technology, 1991 |